MX23RW : Thursday, April 3 19:27:46| >> :120:7516:7516:
[monks data]
Aston Villa logo
Premier League | Gameweek 28
Jun 17, 2020 at 6pm UK
Villa Park
Sheffield United logo

Aston Villa
0 - 0
Sheff Utd


Luiz (27')
FT

Lundstram (36')

Sheffield United ghost goal: What happened? Why didn't VAR intervene? What next?

Sheffield United ghost goal: What happened? Why didn't VAR intervene? What next?
© Reuters
A closer look at the issue which denied Chris Wilder's European hopefuls a goal at Aston Villa.

The Premier League's Project Restart got off to a false start at Villa Park on Wednesday when goal-line technology failed to award a goal to Sheffield United.

Here, the PA news agency takes a closer look at the incident.

What happened?

A free-kick from Oliver Norwood curled towards the Aston Villa goal and was caught by their goalkeeper Oliver Nyland, who stepped back and carried the ball over the line.

Why did the technology fail?

Hawk-Eye, the company which operates the goal-line technology (GLT) system, said it had failed because the seven cameras trained on the goal area had been "significantly occluded" by Nyland, his team-mate Keinan Davis and the post. This level of obstruction had not been witnessed in more than 9,000 matches where the system had been in operation, Hawk-Eye said.

Why didn't the referee award the goal?

Michael Oliver, left, discusses the goal-line incident with Sheffield United's Oliver Norwood
Michael Oliver, left, discusses the goal-line incident with Sheffield United's Oliver Norwood (Carl Recine/PA)

Referee Michael Oliver did not award a goal because he would have been expecting to receive a signal as part of the integrated goal decision system. As no signal was received, he allowed play to continue.

Why didn't the VAR intervene?

For the same reason as Oliver – no signal was received. Because play continued there could not be a review of the incident by the VAR.

Could the VAR have intervened?

There is nothing in the VAR protocols set out by the International Football Association Board (IFAB) which prevent VARs reviewing goal/no goal decisions. However, the ball crossing the line would not have the 'clear and obvious' test applied to it in normal circumstances because, like offside, it is considered an objective rather than a subjective decision, with technology  in theory allowing a better decision to be made.

Will this change how things are done in the future?

Hawk-Eye has apologised for the error, but it is not clear yet whether it will look again at the technology to see whether even such a rare glitch as this can be ironed out.

From a Premier League point of view the incident is viewed as something of a 'perfect storm' and it is unlikely we will get to a position where the VAR routinely questions the goal-line technology. If a goal is given, the VAR would trust the technology to award the goal unless it was immediately obvious that the system had failed.

Will there be a review of this incident?

Referees' chief Mike Riley leads regular debriefing sessions
Referees' chief Mike Riley leads regular debriefing sessions (Christopher Lee/PA)

Premier League referees hold regular debriefing sessions about a whole range of issues, but it is understood there will be no specific inquest into this incident.

ID:402882: cacheID:402882:1false2false3false:QQ:: from db desktop :LenBod:restore:8625:
Written by
P A
No Data Analysis info
Restore Data
Share this article now:
Arsenal captain Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang takes the knee ahead of Arsenal's Premier League match on June 17, 2020
Read Next:
Black Lives Matter: Premier League show support by taking a knee upon restart
>
Read more about Michael Oliver Football
rhs 2.0
Today's games header
Tables header RHS
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
1Liverpool30227170274373
2Arsenal301710355253061
3Nottingham ForestNott'm Forest30176750351557
4Manchester CityMan City30156957401751
5Newcastle UnitedNewcastle29155949391050
6Chelsea29147853371649
7Aston Villa3013984445-148
8Brighton & Hove AlbionBrighton30121174845347
9Fulham3012994440445
10Bournemouth301281049381144
11Brentford30125135147441
12Crystal Palace29101093734340
13Manchester UnitedMan Utd30107133741-437
14Tottenham HotspurSpurs291041555431234
15Everton30713103237-534
16West Ham UnitedWest Ham3097143350-1734
17Wolverhampton WanderersWolves3085174158-1729
18Ipswich TownIpswich3048183063-3320
19Leicester CityLeicester3045212567-4217
20Southampton3024242271-4910


Sports Mole provides in-depth previews and predictions for every match from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football.
Argentina's Lionel Messi kisses the World Cup trophy after collecting the Golden Ball award on December 18, 2022Sign up for our FREE daily preview newsletter direct to your inbox!