Danny Mills has questioned Football Association chairman Greg Dyke's viewpoint just days after being appointed on the chief's commission.
Dyke has backed suggestions that Belgium-born Manchester United youngster Adnan Januzaj could represent the Three Lions in the future.
However, Mills, who was chosen by Dyke to be on the commission, believes that only young English talent should come through the ranks.
"I don't agree with [Dyke on] that," Mills told talkSPORT. "I don't think [Januzaj] should be able to play for England. I think it is a quick fix to a long-term problem. If you start to do that, you actually detract from encouraging young English clubs to go and find English players."
Meanwhile, the England senior squad are preparing to take on Montenegro in their penultimate World Cup qualifier at Wembley this evening.
