MX23RW : Thursday, November 14 23:49:40| >> :600:143499:143499:

Neil Doncaster, John Nelms could give evidence in relegation court battle

The lawyers acting for the SPFL and three promoted clubs have called for the dispute to go before an arbitration panel.

Neil Doncaster and John Nelms could be cross-examined by Hearts and Partick Thistle's legal representative if their battle against relegation is heard in the Court of Session.

The lawyers acting for the Scottish Professional Football League, and promoted clubs Dundee United, Raith Rovers and Cove Rangers, have both called for the dispute to go before an arbitration panel convened by the Scottish Football Association.

But David Thomson QC, acting on behalf of the relegated clubs, claimed the matters were of "significant and legitimate public interest" and should therefore be heard in an open court.

The resolution that ended the season and thus relegated Hearts and Thistle hinged on Dundee, who changed their mind after initially submitting a vote which would have scuppered the plan. The SPFL said Dundee's email had got lost in its quarantine system.

Dundee's vote proved crucial
Dundee's vote proved crucial (PA)

Thomson stated that most of the grounds of the two clubs' complaint were related to documents rather than what anyone saw or heard.

But he added that the "Dundee vote" and the evidence of communications between SPFL chief executive Doncaster and Dundee managing director Nelms were the type of issue which might be subject to evidence and, agreeing with the judge, possibly cross-examination.

Thomson also gave an example of what he branded a "remarkable episode" on June 26 when the SPFL told clubs it was "necessary that they join forces to oppose the petition in order to see the pleadings" following an apparent request from clubs to see court documents.

He added: "That type of episode is a matter of significant concern and legitimate interest which strongly favours hearing the dispute in a public court."

Thomson also claimed there was no valid clause in the SPFL rules that clubs should go to arbitration and, referring to the arbitration clause in the Scottish Football Association articles, argued that his clients had brought the case as SPFL shareholders rather than SFA members.

Garry Borland QC, acting for the three promoted clubs, counter-argued that the SFA article, which states that approval from the governing body's board is needed to start court proceedings, was a precondition of legal action and did not preclude it.

Lord Clark will continue hearing the arguments, as well as Hearts and Partick Thistle's motion for the release of documents, on Friday morning.

ID:404872: cacheID:404872:1false2false3false:QQ:: from db desktop :LenBod:restore:5778:
Restore Data
Share this article now:
Leon Bailey celebrates scoring for Bayern Leverkusen on November 30, 2019
Read Next:
Leon Bailey 'keen on Premier League move'
>
rhs 2.0
Today's games header
Tables header RHS
TeamPWDLFAGDPTS
1Celtic1110103132831
2Aberdeen11101024101431
3RangersRangers11713168822
4Dundee UnitedDundee Utd125431813519
5Motherwell116141514119
6St Mirren134361722-515
7Dundee123361824-612
8Kilmarnock123361525-1012
9Ross County132651021-1112
10St Johnstone133191627-1110
11Hearts132381420-69
12Hibernian121561118-78


Sports Mole provides in-depth previews and predictions for every match from the biggest leagues and competitions in world football.
Argentina's Lionel Messi kisses the World Cup trophy after collecting the Golden Ball award on December 18, 2022Sign up for our FREE daily preview newsletter direct to your inbox!